Bloody Jason vs. Hillbilly Plush: Which Dead by Daylight Collectible Wins?

Quick answer

Choose the Youtooz Bloody Jason figure if you want a detailed, horror-movie crossover piece with a bloody paint job and a compact 4.6-inch footprint. Choose the Phunny Plush Hillbilly if you prefer soft, huggable materials, a taller 7.5-inch presence, and a lower price. Both are officially licensed and built for display, so the real decision comes down to material and shelf style.

Two Dead by Daylight collectibles sit at very different ends of the shelf: a blood-soaked Youtooz figure and a soft Kidrobot plush. One is hard vinyl, the other is stitched fabric, and each changes how your display reads from across the room.

This comparison uses only the catalog facts supplied for each product. It covers size, materials, price positioning, and display trade-offs so you can pick the one that actually fits your collection instead of guessing from photos.

Size and shelf presence

The Bloody Jason figure stands 4.6 inches tall and is posed with his right foot cracking through a red, brown, and blue pallet. That compact height makes it easy to slot onto a crowded shelf, a desk corner, or beside a monitor without rearranging everything around it. The dynamic pose gives it a sense of motion that static figures often lack.

The Phunny Plush Hillbilly stands 7.5 inches tall, which is noticeably taller and wider in the hand. It holds a chainsaw in one bloodied hand and a hammer in the other, so it occupies more vertical and horizontal space. If your shelf is already tight, the plush will demand more room than the figure.

• Measure your shelf depth before buying: the plush is taller but the figure's pallet base adds footprint.
• If you display in a glass case, the 4.6-inch figure fits standard cubbies more easily.

Material and detail

Bloody Jason is a hard vinyl figure with a white and red hockey mask, bare head, and a body drenched in deep red blood. The sculpted details and paint application are the point here. You get sharp edges, a tilted head, and an unseen gaze from the dark eyeholes that reads as genuinely menacing up close.

The Phunny Plush Hillbilly translates the Killer into soft materials. His disfigured face is reproduced in fabric, and the chainsaw and hammer are plush rather than rigid. That softness softens the horror, which is either the appeal or the drawback depending on whether you want a frightening display or a friendly one.

• Vinyl shows dust and fingerprints more readily; keep a soft brush nearby.
• Plush fabric can attract lint and pet hair, so store it away from high-traffic areas.

Price and value positioning

The Bloody Jason figure is listed at USD 15.00 against a catalog comparison price of USD 29.99. The Phunny Plush Hillbilly is listed at USD 8.49 against a catalog comparison price of USD 16.99. Both sit in the affordable collectible range, but the plush is the lower-cost entry point.

Value here is not just about price. The figure gives you a licensed horror crossover with detailed paint, while the plush gives you a larger soft object that is harder to damage by handling. If you plan to keep the item boxed, the figure's sculpt matters more. If you plan to handle it often, the plush is more forgiving.

• Check current pricing before ordering; catalog comparison prices are reference points, not permanent sale prices.
• Buying both is reasonable if you want one hard and one soft piece on the same shelf.

Display and care trade-offs

Vinyl figures like Bloody Jason are best kept out of direct sunlight to slow paint fading, and they should be dusted gently rather than wiped with harsh cleaners. The pallet base is part of the sculpt, so avoid stacking anything on top of it.

The Phunny Plush Hillbilly is easier to spot-clean but can lose shape if squashed. Give it a dedicated spot where it will not be compressed by books or other collectibles. Neither item is described as weather-resistant, so keep both indoors and away from damp areas.

• Rotate displays occasionally to limit one-sided fading.
• Keep plush away from velcro, zippers, and rough fabrics that snag.

The trade-offs, side by side

• Detail vs. softness: Bloody Jason delivers sculpted vinyl detail and bloody paint, while the Hillbilly plush trades sharpness for soft, huggable fabric. Pick the figure for visual impact, the plush for tactile appeal.
• Size vs. space: The figure is 4.6 inches tall with a pallet base; the plush is 7.5 inches tall and wider in the hand. Small shelf: figure. Open shelf or bed: plush.
• Price vs. material: The figure is listed at USD 15.00 and the plush at USD 8.49, but the plush is larger and softer while the figure offers more intricate paint. Budget-first buyers lean plush; detail-first buyers lean figure.

Product facts at a glance

• Dead by Daylight x Youtooz - Bloody Jason: Stands 4.6 inches tall with his right foot cracking through a red, brown, and blue pallet, white and red hockey mask, and a body drenched in deep red blood. Compact and highly detailed, this figure suits collectors who want a horror crossover piece with a dynamic pose and limited shelf space.
• Phunny Plush Hillbilly plush: Stands 7.5 inches tall, holds a chainsaw in one bloodied hand and a hammer in the other, with a disfigured face in soft materials; part of Kidrobot's Phunny line and officially licensed by Behaviour Interactive. Larger and softer, this plush works for collectors who prefer a tactile, lower-cost piece that is harder to damage through handling.

Which one should you get?

Best for

• Collectors who want a detailed, horror-focused vinyl figure with a dynamic pose
• Small shelves, desks, or glass cases where a 4.6-inch footprint fits better
• Fans of the Jason crossover who want the bloody paint and hockey mask look

Not for

• Buyers who prefer soft, huggable materials over hard vinyl
• Shoppers looking for the lowest price point in this comparison
• Anyone who wants a larger, roomier display piece that stands out from a distance

Both collectibles earn their shelf space, but they serve different collectors. If you want detail, a compact footprint, and a bloody horror crossover, go with Bloody Jason. If you want a bigger, softer, lower-cost piece you can handle without worry, the Phunny Plush Hillbilly is the better fit. Match the material to how you actually display and touch your collection, and you will not regret either pick.