Dead by Daylight Soundtrack Volume 1 vs. Volume 2: Which Vinyl Is Better?

Quick answer

Buy Volume 2 while it's here. It's the only Dead by Daylight soundtrack vinyl currently in stock at this store, and the real choice is between the Canada and USA Record Store Day splatter variants, not Volume 1 versus Volume 2. If you want the earlier volume, you'll have to source it elsewhere.

If you're trying to pick between the Dead by Daylight soundtrack on vinyl, the honest starting point is that Volume 1 isn't part of this store's dead by daylight music comparison right now. The only soundtrack pressing in stock is Dead By Daylight Soundtrack Volume 2, and it comes in two Record Store Day exclusives: a white splatter Canada variant and a black splatter USA variant. Both are listed at USD 10.98 against a USD 21.95 comparison price.

That changes the question. Instead of a straight volume 1 vs volume 2 vinyl shootout, this is a comparison of the two Volume 2 pressings you can actually add to your cart, plus a clear note on what to do if you specifically want Volume 1.

What's actually available for the DBD soundtrack on vinyl

This store carries Dead By Daylight Soundtrack Volume 2 in two Record Store Day exclusive splatter variants. The Canada exclusive is white splatter; the USA exclusive is black splatter. Both are described as leftover copies of a long out-of-print Record Store Day release, and both ship from Canada, fulfilled by Return to Analog Records.

Volume 1 is not listed in the supplied catalog here. That's a decision limitation, not a judgment on the music. If you want Volume 1, you'll need to look at secondhand marketplaces or other retailers, and you should expect to verify the pressing and condition yourself before buying.

• Both Volume 2 variants list the same price and the same tracklist, including Darkness Among Us, Hiding, Flesh And Bones, Carousel Nightmare, and Lunar on Side A.
• Both variants ship separately from other purchases in your order because they're fulfilled by Return to Analog Records.

White splatter vs. black splatter: the real trade-off

The two Volume 2 pressings differ mainly in colorway and regional exclusivity. White splatter is the Canada Record Store Day exclusive; black splatter is the USA Record Store Day exclusive. If you collect by region, that distinction is the whole point. If you just want the music on vinyl, either one plays the same tracklist.

Because both ship from Canada, the USA exclusive doesn't get you faster domestic shipping. The practical difference for most buyers comes down to which colorway you prefer on the turntable and whether you're completing a regional set.

• Pick white splatter if you want the lighter, higher-contrast look or you're building a Canada RSD collection.
• Pick black splatter if you prefer a darker pressing or you're collecting USA RSD exclusives.

Should you wait for Volume 1?

Only wait if you're committed to owning the full set in order. Volume 2 is described as long out-of-print, so leftover copies at this price are a finite situation. Waiting for a Volume 1 listing that may never appear here risks missing Volume 2 at USD 10.98.

If you're new to the soundtrack, there's no rule that says you must start with Volume 1. The Volume 2 tracklist stands on its own, and the store's own description suggests putting it on while you play. That's a reasonable way to enjoy it without owning the earlier release.

• If you find a Volume 1 copy elsewhere, check the pressing details and sleeve condition before paying collector prices.
• Don't buy a Volume 1 listing just to complete a set if you haven't confirmed it's the pressing you actually want.

Display and care notes for either pressing

Both Volume 2 variants are standard vinyl records, so the care basics are the same: store them upright, keep them out of direct sun, and use a clean stylus. The splatter colorways show dust and fingerprints a little more readily than plain black, so a quick brush before each play is worth the habit.

If you're displaying the record, the colorway is the visual feature. Frame or shelf it where light hits the splatter pattern, but keep it away from heat sources that can warp the disc.

• Handle by the edges and label only.
• Keep the inner sleeve if you plan to resell or trade later.

Trade-offs to weigh before you buy

• Volume 2 availability vs. Volume 1 absence: Volume 2 is in stock in two variants; Volume 1 is not listed here at all. Buying Volume 2 now means you own part of the soundtrack, not the whole set. If completing the set matters more than price, source Volume 1 first and accept you may pay more for it.
• White splatter vs. black splatter: Identical price, identical tracklist, different regional exclusivity and colorway. Both ship from Canada. Choose by color preference and regional collection goals, not by shipping speed.
• Buying now vs. waiting: These are described as leftover copies of a long out-of-print release. Stock is not guaranteed to last or to be restocked. If you want Volume 2 at USD 10.98, don't wait for a Volume 1 listing that isn't here.
• Separate shipping: Vinyl orders are fulfilled by Return to Analog Records and ship separately from other items in your cart. Expect more than one package if you're also buying apparel or prints.

Catalog facts that matter

• Dead By Daylight Soundtrack Volume 2 (White Splatter - Canada Record Store Day Exclusive): Canada Record Store Day exclusive on white splatter vinyl, listed at USD 10.98 against a USD 21.95 comparison price, described as leftover copies of a long out-of-print release, fulfilled by Return to Analog Records and shipped from Canada. This is the lighter colorway and the Canada regional exclusive, so it's the one to choose if you collect Canadian RSD pressings or want a brighter look on the shelf.
• Dead By Daylight Soundtrack Volume 2 (Black Splatter - USA Record Store Day Exclusive): USA Record Store Day exclusive on black splatter vinyl, listed at USD 10.98 against a USD 21.95 comparison price, described as leftover copies of a long out-of-print release, fulfilled by Return to Analog Records and shipped from Canada. Same price and same tracklist as the Canada variant, so the choice is about the darker colorway and the USA regional label rather than sound or content.

Who should buy which

Best for

• Fans who want the Dead by Daylight soundtrack on vinyl right now and don't need Volume 1 to enjoy it
• Collectors of Record Store Day exclusives who want either the Canada white splatter or USA black splatter pressing
• Buyers who want a lower-cost entry into DBD vinyl at USD 10.98

Not for

• Collectors who require Volume 1 first and won't buy out of order
• Buyers who need a specific non-splatter or standard black pressing, which isn't listed here
• Anyone expecting both volumes to ship together, since only Volume 2 is available

If you want the Dead by Daylight soundtrack on vinyl today, pick the Volume 2 splatter that matches your collection and color taste, and treat Volume 1 as a separate search. At USD 10.98 for a long out-of-print Record Store Day pressing, the bigger risk is waiting.